Trump-DB-Qatar Nexus

The Trump-DB-Qatar Nexus is a documented set of financial and diplomatic relationships that converge on Deutsche Bank as a shared institutional node. Deutsche Bank served as Donald Trump's primary commercial lender — the only major US financial institution willing to extend credit to Trump following his 1990s Atlantic City bankruptcies — issuing a USD 640 million construction loan for the Trump International Hotel and Tower Chicago in February 2005, with a USD 40 million personal guarantee. Concurrently, Deutsche Bank held accounts for Jeffrey Epstein, managed through HBRK Associates Inc and structured entities including the Haze Trust and the Butterfly Trust, until DB closed all Epstein-related accounts in early 2019. The Qatar Investment Authority — the Gulf state's sovereign wealth fund — held approximately 6 percent of Deutsche Bank's equity as of 2017, making it one of DB's largest institutional shareholders. In July 2017, Epstein explicitly framed this three-way relationship to New York Times journalist Landon Thomas Jr. as a single structural fact: Qatar owned DB, DB funded Trump, and Trump — against the advice of Secretary of State Rex Tillerson — was backing the Saudi-led diplomatic blockade of Qatar. Epstein was operating simultaneously as a Deutsche Bank client and as an active informal intermediary to Qatari principals, including Jabor Yousuf Jassim Al Thani and his uncle, former Qatari Prime Minister Hamad bin Jassim Al Thani.

Jeffrey Epstein
10 findings 0 connections 0 entities

On July 20, 2017 — six weeks into the Saudi-UAE-led diplomatic blockade of Qatar — Jeffrey Epstein sent a single-sentence email to Landon Thomas Jr., a New York Times financial reporter: "qatar is the biggest shareholder in DB. db is donalds funder. donald goes after qatar for terrorsim against the advice of tillerson and state. ie DB?" 1. The question mark at the end was addressed to Thomas. Thomas replied that he was preparing a lengthy profile of Tom Barrack — and did not engage with the substance 2.

Each factual component of Epstein's message is independently verifiable. QIA's approximately 6 percent stake in Deutsche Bank is documented in DB's 20-F annual reports filed with the SEC, and GLEIF registration records indicate QIA's status as a sovereign wealth fund based in Doha 3. Deutsche Bank's role as Trump's primary commercial lender — including a USD 640 million construction loan for the Chicago tower in 2005 — is documented in public litigation records 4. The Saudi-UAE-led blockade of Qatar began June 5, 2017, and Secretary of State Tillerson's opposition to the US posture of backing the blockade was reported contemporaneously 4.

What the email documents is not a novel financial relationship but Epstein's awareness of it, his framing of it as a leverage dynamic, and the identity of the person he chose to surface it to. Epstein was, at the time, both a Deutsche Bank client himself and an active informal channel to the Qatari principals most directly affected by the blockade 5, 6, 7.

The Deutsche Bank Lending Relationship

Deutsche Bank became Donald Trump's primary commercial banker following Trump's 1990s bankruptcies across his Atlantic City casino properties. By the mid-2000s, no major US financial institution other than Deutsche Bank was extending significant credit to Trump's real estate operations. The largest documented transaction is the February 2005 issuance of a USD 640 million construction loan for the Trump International Hotel and Tower in Chicago, with Trump providing a USD 40 million personal guarantee. Trump defaulted on the personal guarantee in November 2008, then sued Deutsche Bank for USD 3 billion, claiming the bank's own conduct had contributed to the real estate market disruption. The litigation settled. Deutsche Bank continued lending to Trump Organization properties through the 2010s 4, 8.

A secondary financial intersection between Trump and Deutsche Bank runs through the Palm Beach property chain. Trump Properties LLC purchased Maison de l'Amitie — a Palm Beach mansion previously owned by Leslie Wexner — from the Gosman bankruptcy estate for USD 41.35 million in November 2004, financed by Deutsche Bank. The property was sold to Russian fertilizer billionaire Dmitry Rybolovlev for USD 95 million in 2008 via County Road Property LLC, generating over USD 50 million in proceeds. Epstein had served as the court-approved stalking horse bidder for the same property in the 2004 bankruptcy proceeding, and was familiar with the transaction in granular detail: he edited Michael Wolff's manuscript description of the deal in February 2019, correcting the sale price to 'stalking horse at 36m' and noting Trump 'should have had a 50 million plus capital gain' 910.

The Chicago guarantee came due in November 2008 — four months after Rybolovlev's USD 95 million purchase closed, generating proceeds sufficient to cover it. Epstein flagged this timing in materials he provided to Wolff. The connection between the two transactions is documented in Epstein's own written narrative, not established independently by this investigation 4, 8.

Qatar Investment Authority Ownership and the 2017 Blockade

The Qatar Investment Authority was established by Emiri Decree No. 22 in 2005 and is registered as a sovereign wealth fund and resident government entity under GLEIF LEI 5493008JZL5CRK3VS565. Its registered address is Ooredoo Tower (Building 14), Dafna Street, Al Dafna District, Doha. As of 2017, QIA held approximately 6 percent of Deutsche Bank's ordinary shares, making it one of the institution's largest shareholders. This shareholding is documented in Deutsche Bank's 20-F annual reports filed with the SEC. Analysis of available EDGAR records indicates that text-index search did not return the Qatar Holdings entries, and verification requires direct review of the 20-F filings under CIK 1159508 3.

The blockade of Qatar by Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain, and Egypt began June 5, 2017. Within the Trump administration, the positions were divided: Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and the State Department opposed a sharp US tilt toward the blockading states, while the White House — and specifically Jared Kushner — aligned more closely with Saudi and UAE positions. Trump's public statements in June 2017 backed the blockade. Tillerson's disagreement was contemporaneously reported. Epstein's July 20, 2017 email to Thomas identifies this intra-administration split as the context for the financial triangle: his framing is that Trump was backing the blockade of his own bank's largest shareholder 1112.

Separately, Epstein had been an active informal intermediary to Qatari principals since at least 2012. Jabor Yousuf Jassim Al Thani — documented in 30+ DOJ files spanning 2012 to 2019 — communicated with Epstein through the blockade period. On May 6, 2017, two weeks before Trump's Riyadh trip that preceded the blockade, Epstein invited Jabor and his uncle (Hamad bin Jassim Al Thani, former Prime Minister and Foreign Minister of Qatar) to visit 9 East 71st Street to discuss the forthcoming trip: "if you and or your uncle want to come to visit after art shopping to talk more about trump middle east trip at the end of the month" 5. On July 6, 2017 — one month into the blockade — Epstein provided Jabor a nine-point advisory memo including the guidance to "follow Modi model: danced and sang in Israel for benefit of US president IT WORKED" 6.

The Alrasheed channel provided parallel Saudi-side intelligence. Anas Alrasheed — a Saudi contact with 70 documented communications — coordinated with Epstein during the blockade, providing real-time reporting on Kuwaiti Emir Sabah's mediation efforts between Riyadh and Doha 13. Alrasheed has no FARA registration despite documented transmission of Saudi government intelligence 14.

5 visible · 5 emphasized · grouped by type
Overview (drag to set timeline window)
Key Events
Selected Event
Select an event to inspect context and evidence scaffolding.
Default view communicates key events; interactions add context and detail.

Epstein's Deutsche Bank Account Architecture

Epstein maintained over 40 Deutsche Bank accounts between August 2013 and early 2019, managed through the bank's wealth management division under relationship manager code RM 81851. The accounts were administered through Richard Kahn's entity HBRK Associates Inc — a New York domestic business corporation (NY-SoS DOS ID 3714818, filed August 29, 2008) with Kahn as both registered agent and process server at his personal residence, 1365 York Avenue Apt. 28, New York, NY 10021. HBRK held three Deutsche Bank accounts (44129914, 42953715, 42953694) with a peak balance of USD 199,440 in May 2017. On December 12, 2019 — approximately four months after Epstein's death — HBRK received USD 9.24 million across seven incoming wire transfers as a final DB account closure and estate distribution 1516.

The Haze Trust — a New York grantor trust formed February 2, 1999, EIN 43-7185414, with Darren Indyke as trustee and Epstein as grantor and beneficiary — held the largest Deutsche Bank account architecture in the record. Three accounts (42953236, 44129543, 42967287) were opened September 24, 2013, with a registered address at 6100 Red Hook Quarters, Suite 83, St. Thomas, USVI. The balance trajectory recorded in DS10 Deutsche Bank internal records shows the accounts dormant through late 2016, then surging: USD 1,000 (April 2017), USD 21.02 million (May 2017), USD 4.25 million (October 2017 — following a USD 13 million internal transfer on October 26, EFTA01287132), USD 19.12 million (November 2017), USD 2.50 million (July 2018), and USD 0 (August 2018). According to DugganUSA investment account statements 171819, the Haze Trust maintained an active portfolio from February 2012 with a beginning market value of USD 6.4 million 20.

In March 2019, Epstein's advisors attempted to use the Haze Trust to purchase the Bin Ennakhil palace in Marrakech for approximately USD 23 million, routing the transaction through Deutsche Bank and LGT Bank Liechtenstein. The attempt failed because Deutsche Bank had already closed the Haze Trust accounts. No Haze Trust property was recorded in NYC's ACRIS property database. Examination of ACRIS records found that all 22 Epstein-affiliated entities searched returned zero results 20, 21.

Deutsche Bank's relationship with Epstein ended formally in early 2019. The New York State Department of Financial Services subsequently fined the bank USD 150 million, with part of the penalty attributed to failures in monitoring Epstein-related accounts. SDNY investigated the relationship; William Barr, as Attorney General, oversaw the DOJ during the period when both Deutsche Bank and Epstein's own criminal case were under federal scrutiny Connection #1538.

Tom Barrack as Bridging Node

When Landon Thomas received Epstein's Qatar-DB-Trump email and did not engage with it, he pivoted to the story he was actually working on: a profile of Tom Barrack 2. Barrack's position in the network makes this redirection structurally notable. LittleSis documents him as a close friend of both Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein, a friend of Jared Kushner and Hamad bin Jassim Al Thani, and a lender to Paul Manafort for USD 1.5 million 22. He chaired the 58th Presidential Inaugural Committee, which raised a record USD 107 million; the SDNY investigated the committee's foreign donor relationships without resulting in an indictment 23.

Barrack served as a direct conduit between Gulf state principals and Epstein's network. DOJ files document Colony Capital's Esther Kaplan coordinating a meeting between Barrack and H.E. Sheikh Hamad (Hamad bin Jassim Al Thani, former Qatari Prime Minister) at Epstein's 9 East 71st Street office 24. Sheikh Hamad separately requested a time change for a meeting at 71st Street 25. Barrack and Sheikh Hamad were documented no-shows at an Epstein dinner 26. Colony Capital's Middle East and North Africa investment network — managed through Rashid Al Malik's Dubai connections — made Barrack the natural Gulf-facing intermediary within the Trump orbit 7.

Epstein used Barrack's access explicitly to signal to Gulf contacts. In January 2017, Sultan Bin Sulayem (DP World chairman) asked Epstein whether to accept an invitation from Barrack to the inauguration. Epstein replied with a CNN article; the same day he forwarded Barrack-inauguration coverage to Aziza Alahmadi and Raafat Alsabbagh; three days later he sent LA Times Barrack-inauguration coverage to Alahmadi, Terje Rod-Larsen, and Alsabbagh, and separately to Sultan 27. Network analysis places Barrack as the fourth-highest hub in the non-Epstein subgraph with 34 connections 28.

Barrack was indicted in 2021 on charges of acting as an unregistered foreign agent of the UAE, with co-defendant Matthew Grimes and UAE national Rashid Al-Malik charged alongside him (E.D.N.Y. 1:21-cr-00371). He was acquitted in October 2022. Al-Malik was separately convicted 29.

Epstein as Intelligence Aggregator

The July 2017 email to Thomas was not Epstein's only documentation of the Qatar-DB-Trump triangle. Finding #1060 records that the same message was described in the DOJ corpus as reflecting Epstein's tracking of the "Qatar-Deutsche Bank-Trump triangle" and explicitly notes his observation of "the irony of Trump attacking his own bank's largest shareholder." The formulation is Epstein's own, expressing a view that the geopolitical crisis had a financial logic that US media was not covering.

Epstein was simultaneously receiving real-time intelligence from both sides of the blockade. On the Saudi side, Anas Alrasheed — who had 70 documented communications with Epstein — was transmitting information about Kuwait's mediation track and Saudi positioning, without FARA registration 13, 14. On the Qatari side, Jabor Al Thani was communicating with Epstein directly throughout the crisis period, and Epstein's nine-point advisory memo of July 6, 2017 6 reflects familiarity with Qatari internal Foreign Ministry weaknesses and international pressure points. His suggestion that Qatar consider recognizing Israel or creating a USD 1 billion terrorism victim fund administered by the US, UK, and UN tracks the actual diplomatic track the blockade eventually took.

Earlier in 2016 and 2017, Epstein had established himself in European financial circles as a Trump interpreter. A February 2017 message to Ariane de Rothschild — following a meeting in Megève — captures his posture: "everyone in govt wanting an explanation of trump. SO MUCH FUN" 30. The Qatar blockade email to Thomas in July 2017 fits the same pattern: Epstein presenting himself to a financial journalist as someone who grasped the structural logic of events that others were missing.

All Findings

10 total
financial medium 2004-11

Trump Properties LLC purchased Maison de l Amitie Palm Beach for 41.35M out of Gosman bankruptcy Nov 2004, financed by Deutsche Bank. Epstein stated ultimate owner unknown. Sold to Rybolovlev for 95M in 2008 via County Road Property LLC. Epstein alleged DB loan guaranteed by entity controlled by Rybolovlev via Xitrans Finance Ltd BVI and Cyprus trust. Abe Gosman called Ghislaine Maxwell Apr 2004 around time of sale.

financial high 2017-07-20

Epstein email to Landon Thomas (Jul 20, 2017): 'qatar is the biggest shareholder in DB. db is donalds funder. donald goes after qatar for terrorsim against the advice of tillerson and state. ie DB?' Epstein explicitly connected Qatar's DB ownership to Trump's DB dependence and the diplomatic crisis.

financial high 2017-07-20

Landon Thomas reply to Epstein's Qatar-DB-Trump email (Jul 20, 2017 2:00 PM): 'Often times no\! Am getting ready to approach Barrack for a lengthy profile.' Thomas deflected the Qatar-DB question and pivoted to Tom Barrack. EFTA02368670 is the reply with the original quoted.

financial confirmed 2008-08-29

HBRK Associates Inc. (Richard Kahn entity) confirmed as NY corporation via NY Secretary of State: DOS ID 3714818, filed Aug 29, 2008, type Domestic Business Corporation, county New York, jurisdiction New York. Process server and registered agent: Richard Kahn, address 1365 York Avenue Apt. 28, New York NY 10021 (Kahn personal residence). DS10 financial records confirm HBRK held Deutsche Bank accounts (acct 44129914, 42953715, 42953694) with peak balance $199,440 (May 2017). On Dec 12, 2019 (post-Epstein death), HBRK received $9.24M across 7 incoming transfers as final DB account closure/estate distribution. Outgoing activity was minimal: $12.15 to Ulster Savings Bank (Aug 2015) and $3,000 to JPMorgan Chase (Oct 2017). JP Morgan account 799789169 also confirmed for regular check activity.

[file] DS10
+3 more sources
financial medium 2013-09-24

DS10 Deutsche Bank internal records confirm The Haze Trust account architecture: multiple DB accounts (42953236, 44129543, 42967287) opened Sep 24, 2013. Balance trajectory: $0 (Sep-Nov 2013) -> $1K (Apr 2017) -> $21.02M (May 2017) -> $4.25M (Oct 2017) -> $19.12M (Nov 2017) -> $2.50M (Jul 2018) -> $0 (Aug 2018). Two outgoing transactions: $131.44 to BNP Paribas SA (May 2, 2017, EFTA01299387) and $13M internal transfer (Oct 26, 2017, EFTA01287132). Peak balance $21.02M. Haze Trust address confirmed at 6100 Red Hook Qtrs Suite 83, St Thomas VI (EFTA01344082, marked DB-SDNY-0029206). DugganUSA returns investment account statements (EFTA01501998, EFTA01502283, EFTA01502442) showing active portfolio from Feb 2012 through 2013+ with beginning market value $6.4M. Haze Trust was used for attempted $23M Bin Ennakhil palace purchase in Marrakech (Mar 2019) via Deutsche Bank and LGT Bank Liechtenstein, but DB had closed the accounts. No property recorded in ACRIS under Haze name.

[file] DS10
+10 more sources
financial medium 2005-01-01

Qatar Investment Authority (QIA) confirmed as sovereign wealth fund via GLEIF LEI 5493008JZL5CRK3VS565. Category: RESIDENT_GOVERNMENT_ENTITY, subcategory: STATE_GOVERNMENT. Legal form: Sovereign Wealth Fund. Jurisdiction: Qatar. Address: Ooredoo Tower (Building 14), Dafna Street, Al Dafna District, Doha. Created 2005-01-01. Active status. QIA has at least one direct subsidiary: Jade Holding LLC (LEI 2549004U6K21MGN3L374, Doha, registered as #03986). Epstein's own statement (Finding #1060, Jul 20 2017 email to Landon Thomas Jr): 'qatar is the biggest shareholder in DB. db is donalds funder. donald goes after qatar for terrorism against the advice of tillerson and state ie DB?' The Qatar shareholding in Deutsche Bank (~6% as of 2017) is widely documented in DB 20-F annual reports filed with SEC. However, our SEC EDGAR full-text search for 'Qatar Investment Authority Deutsche Bank' and 'Qatar Holdings Deutsche' returned zero hits in the filing text index, meaning the Qatar shareholding must be verified through the DB annual reports (filed as 20-F under CIK 1159508) rather than text search.

relationship medium

Network analysis: 675 nodes, 1072 edges, 13 components. Non-Epstein subgraph contains 70% of all edges (1009/1447). Top non-Epstein hubs: Indyke (67), Thiel (58), Black (36), Barrack (34)

Graph analysis run #1 on 2857 findings/1447 connections. Key metrics: avg degree 3.18, max degree 262 (Epstein), density 0.0047. 131 bridge nodes, 178 structural holes (min degree 3), 41 cliques (min size 3). 104 cross-thread actors identified. Largest component: 643 nodes (95%). Non-Epstein top hubs indicate these are independently significant actors, not just Epstein satellites: Indyke=legal infrastructure, Thiel=tech/finance, Black=Apollo, Barrack=Gulf/political, 2017 Caterpillar Trust=financial vehicle.

legal medium

Alrasheed (Saudi Arabian Epstein contact, 70 emails, KSA touchline/Qatar blockade intelligence) has no FARA registration. Saudi Arabia has 270 FARA-registered foreign principals. Alrasheed's documented role transmitting Saudi government intelligence to Epstein (Qatar blockade context, KSA political positioning) without FARA registration suggests undisclosed foreign agent activity. Similarly, Sulayem (UAE) and Alahmadi (Saudi, 10M palace) have zero FARA presence.

intelligence high 2017

Alrasheed coordinated with Epstein during 2017 Qatar blockade, providing real-time intelligence on Kuwaiti Emir Sabah's mediation with Saudi and Qatar. Epstein discussed communication protocols and subjects (economic, military, tech) with Alrasheed.

document medium

ACRIS search notable absences: Ghislaine Maxwell, Lesley Groff, LSJE LLC, NES LLC, Ossa Properties LLC, Haze Trust, Nautilus Inc, Laurel Inc, Cypress Inc, HBRK Associates, DKIP LLC, M Epstein Family Holdings LLC, BV70 LLC, 1953 Trust, RDK Asset Management, Butterfly Trust (Epstein version), Enhanced Education, Gratitude America, Financial Trust Company, Jeepers Inc, Southern Trust Company, and ERGO Ltd all returned ZERO results in NYC ACRIS real property parties. This suggests these entities either: (a) did not transact in NYC real property, (b) operated through other named entities, or (c) are registered in other jurisdictions (USVI, FL, NM) without NYC property involvement.

Full Timeline

5 events
Qatar Investment Authority (QIA) confirmed as sovereign wealth fund via GLEIF LEI 5493008JZL5CRK3VS565. Category: RESIDENT_GOVERNMENT_ENTITY, subcategory: STATE_GOVERNMENT. Legal form: Sovereign Wealth Fund. Jurisdiction: Qatar. Address: Ooredoo Tower (Building 14), Dafna Street, Al Dafna District, Doha. Created 2005-01-01. Active status. QIA has at least one direct subsidiary: Jade Holding LLC (LEI 2549004U6K21MGN3L374, Doha, registered as #03986). Epstein's own statement (Finding #1060, Jul 20 2017 email to Landon Thomas Jr): 'qatar is the biggest shareholder in DB. db is donalds funder. donald goes after qatar for terrorism against the advice of tillerson and state ie DB?' The Qatar shareholding in Deutsche Bank (~6% as of 2017) is widely documented in DB 20-F annual reports filed with SEC. However, our SEC EDGAR full-text search for 'Qatar Investment Authority Deutsche Bank' and 'Qatar Holdings Deutsche' returned zero hits in the filing text index, meaning the Qatar shareholding must be verified through the DB annual reports (filed as 20-F under CIK 1159508) rather than text search.
2005-01-01
HBRK Associates Inc. (Richard Kahn entity) confirmed as NY corporation via NY Secretary of State: DOS ID 3714818, filed Aug 29, 2008, type Domestic Business Corporation, county New York, jurisdiction New York. Process server and registered agent: Richard Kahn, address 1365 York Avenue Apt. 28, New York NY 10021 (Kahn personal residence). DS10 financial records confirm HBRK held Deutsche Bank accounts (acct 44129914, 42953715, 42953694) with peak balance $199,440 (May 2017). On Dec 12, 2019 (post-Epstein death), HBRK received $9.24M across 7 incoming transfers as final DB account closure/estate distribution. Outgoing activity was minimal: $12.15 to Ulster Savings Bank (Aug 2015) and $3,000 to JPMorgan Chase (Oct 2017). JP Morgan account 799789169 also confirmed for regular check activity.
2008-08-29
DS10 Deutsche Bank internal records confirm The Haze Trust account architecture: multiple DB accounts (42953236, 44129543, 42967287) opened Sep 24, 2013. Balance trajectory: $0 (Sep-Nov 2013) -> $1K (Apr 2017) -> $21.02M (May 2017) -> $4.25M (Oct 2017) -> $19.12M (Nov 2017) -> $2.50M (Jul 2018) -> $0 (Aug 2018). Two outgoing transactions: $131.44 to BNP Paribas SA (May 2, 2017, EFTA01299387) and $13M internal transfer (Oct 26, 2017, EFTA01287132). Peak balance $21.02M. Haze Trust address confirmed at 6100 Red Hook Qtrs Suite 83, St Thomas VI (EFTA01344082, marked DB-SDNY-0029206). DugganUSA returns investment account statements (EFTA01501998, EFTA01502283, EFTA01502442) showing active portfolio from Feb 2012 through 2013+ with beginning market value $6.4M. Haze Trust was used for attempted $23M Bin Ennakhil palace purchase in Marrakech (Mar 2019) via Deutsche Bank and LGT Bank Liechtenstein, but DB had closed the accounts. No property recorded in ACRIS under Haze name.
2013-09-24
Epstein email to Landon Thomas (Jul 20, 2017): 'qatar is the biggest shareholder in DB. db is donalds funder. donald goes after qatar for terrorsim against the advice of tillerson and state. ie DB?' Epstein explicitly connected Qatar's DB ownership to Trump's DB dependence and the diplomatic crisis.
2017-07-20
Landon Thomas reply to Epstein's Qatar-DB-Trump email (Jul 20, 2017 2:00 PM): 'Often times no\! Am getting ready to approach Barrack for a lengthy profile.' Thomas deflected the Qatar-DB question and pivoted to Tom Barrack. EFTA02368670 is the reply with the original quoted.
2017-07-20
  1. 1.Finding #2572
  2. 2.Finding #2573
  3. 3.Finding #2576
  4. 4.Finding #304
  5. 5.Finding #1062
  6. 6.Finding #1049
  7. 7.Finding #2802
  8. 8.Finding #209
  9. 9.Finding #184
  10. 10.Finding #349
  11. 11.Finding #1060
  12. 12.EFTA02643168
  13. 13.Finding #248
  14. 14.Finding #402
  15. 15.Finding #2574
  16. 16.EFTA01344082
  17. 17.EFTA01501998
  18. 18.EFTA01502283
  19. 19.EFTA01502442
  20. 20.Finding #2575
  21. 21.Finding #494
  22. 22.Finding #2798
  23. 23.Finding #2805
  24. 24.EFTA02298819
  25. 25.EFTA02299578
  26. 26.EFTA02523263
  27. 27.Finding #2771
  28. 28.Finding #2859
  29. 29.Finding #3807
  30. 30.Finding #1249